| | Wizard of Oz, The | 7 | 1939 |
| | Philadelphia Story, The | 7.1 | 1940 |
| | Westerner, The | 6.4 | 1940 |
| | Kitty Foyle | 5.8 | 1940 |
| | Great McGinty, The | 6 | 1940 |
| | His Girl Friday | 7.2 | 1940 |
| | Pinocchio | 6.7 | 1940 |
| | Great Dictator, The | 7.5 | 1940 |
| | Grapes of Wrath, The | 7.6 | 1940 |
| | Rebecca | 7.4 | 1940 |
| | Fantasia | 6.7 | 1940 |
| | How Green Was My Valley | 7.3 | 1941 |
| | Sergeant York | 5.9 | 1941 |
| | Here Comes Mr. Jordan | 7.1 | 1941 |
| | Lady Eve, The | 6.9 | 1941 |
| | Great Lie, The | 6 | 1941 |
| | Suspicion | 6.5 | 1941 |
| | Johnny Eager | 6.2 | 1941 |
| | Maltese Falcon, The | 7.3 | 1941 |
| | Citizen Kane | 7.5 | 1941 |
| | Dumbo | 6.5 | 1941 |
| | Mrs. Miniver | 7 | 1942 |
| | Now, Voyager | 7.1 | 1942 |
| | Magnificent Ambersons, The | 6.7 | 1942 |
| | Pride of the Yankees, The | 7.2 | 1942 |