| | Tree Grows in Brooklyn, A | 7.2 | 1945 |
| | Lost Weekend, The | 7.4 | 1945 |
| | Bells of St. Mary's, The | 6.7 | 1945 |
| | Seventh Veil, The | 7 | 1945 |
| | Spellbound | 7 | 1945 |
| | Mildred Pierce | 7.6 | 1945 |
| | Best Years of Our Lives, The | 7.7 | 1946 |
| | Great Expectations | 7.1 | 1946 |
| | Yearling, The | 6.2 | 1946 |
| | Duel in the Sun | 5.9 | 1946 |
| | My Darling Clementine | 7.2 | 1946 |
| | To Each His Own | 6.6 | 1946 |
| | Notorious | 7.2 | 1946 |
| | Razor's Edge, The | 7.1 | 1946 |
| | Big Sleep, The | 7.3 | 1946 |
| | It's a Wonderful Life | 7.8 | 1946 |
| | Double Life, A | 5.8 | 1947 |
| | Ghost and Mrs. Muir, The | 7.1 | 1947 |
| | Gentleman's Agreement | 6.7 | 1947 |
| | Bachelor and the Bobby-Soxer, The | 6.3 | 1947 |
| | Black Narcissus | 7.1 | 1947 |
| | Brighton Rock | 6.5 | 1947 |
| | Out of the Past | 7.4 | 1947 |
| | Farmer's Daughter, The | 6.5 | 1947 |
| | Odd Man Out | 7.4 | 1947 |